SCOTUS Deals Blow to Mexico’s Lawsuit Against U.S. Gunmakers—Cory Booker Reacts with Outrage

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) delivered a resounding verdict this week, unanimously dismissing a lawsuit filed by the Mexican government against several major U.S. gun manufacturers. The ruling reinforces the legal protections granted under the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA), shielding firearm producers from liability tied to gun violence in foreign countries.

Filed in 2021, Mexico’s lawsuit alleged that American companies such as Smith & Wesson, Glock, and Colt willfully enabled the illicit gun trade by selling weapons to dealers who then funneled them into Mexico—where they have frequently been found at crime scenes.

However, the high court disagreed. In her written opinion, Justice Elena Kagan emphasized that Mexico’s claims lacked legal standing.

From the website : Steve Bannon Demands Pentagon Probe Elon Musk Over China Briefing Push: A Growing National Security Storm

“Mexico’s complaint does not plausibly allege that the defendant manufacturers aided and abetted gun dealers’ unlawful sales of firearms to Mexican traffickers.”

She acknowledged the issue of arms smuggling but underscored the lack of substantive evidence tying U.S. gunmakers directly to the violence.

“We have little doubt that, as the complaint asserts, some such sales take place — and that the manufacturers know they do. But still, Mexico has not adequately pleaded what it needs to.”

Cory Booker Calls for Legislative Action

The ruling was met with fierce criticism from Sen. Cory Booker, a prominent Democrat from New Jersey, who expressed disappointment on X

“The Supreme Court’s decision preventing Smith & Wesson from being held accountable for putting weapons of war onto the streets is why Congress needs to pass the Equal Access to Justice for Victims of Gun Violence Act. Americans impacted by the scourge of gun violence deserve better.”

Booker argues that the ruling underscores the urgent need for congressional reform. His proposed legislation would repeal the PLCAA, potentially exposing gun manufacturers to civil lawsuits tied to gun-related crimes.

From the website : Marjorie Taylor Greene Issues Alarming Warning About AI Ban Buried in Massive Federal Bill

Legal Experts Support the Decision

Legal analysts applauded the Supreme Court’s ruling as a win for the rule of law and a reaffirmation of American sovereignty over its internal firearm policies.

According to experts, allowing foreign governments to sue U.S. companies over domestic policies could set a dangerous precedent. “This ruling preserves the integrity of U.S. legal protections and avoids international interference in domestic law,” said Mark Oliva, spokesperson for the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

What This Means for Gun Control Advocates

The SCOTUS decision further complicates the already heated debate over gun control in America. It also places pressure on Congress to revisit the legal shield enjoyed by firearms manufacturers.

Meanwhile, Mexico has not ruled out other legal avenues. Government officials suggested they may pursue action in international courts or explore bilateral agreements to stem the flow of weapons.